Monday, December 15, 2008
Past as Prologue
12:24 PM | Posted by
Mike |
Edit Post
Years ago in college, I wrote an economics paper about a financial crisis that threatened to plunge the world economy into a deep depression.
The elements will seem familiar to us today: webs of high risk loans backed by webs of highly leveraged real-estate collateral, political turmoil in the Middle East, an indifferent government forced to intervene... you get the picture.
The setting? Rome. ca 33 AD.
The Middle East (Judea) was in turmoil because of a certain political rabble-rouser that was going around telling people to be nice to each other. (He was eventually imprisoned and killed by religous fundamentalists.)
That year, an unexpected hurricane sunk several grain ships travelling back from Alexandria to Ostia. That loss triggered calls on the loans for the merchants. Their insurers were unable to make full restitution without calling in more loan markers.
Money lending in the Roman context was a family enterprise -- the landed aristocracy would lend each other money as part of political patronage, with the family estates as collateral. They would spread these loans out as far as possible, creating a web of interlocking financial dependencies that while supposedly "spreading the risk", in reality created a house of cards that would collapse of its own complexity.
Once one of the loans was called -- it triggered a financial meltdown... and in those days, if you lost your estates, you also were likely to lose your freedom (as well as your family's).
Well, eventually, the entire Roman order was threatened and the emperor had to intervene and back the loans with the Privy Purse -- somewhat unprecedented, but then again, so was the Roman Empire.
All of which goes to show that the latest economic crisis is merely the latest in a long line of "been-there-done-that" events. It's just that we (as a society and economy) have little long-term memory when in comes down to it -- about every third generation gets in a bind by first ignoring history, second unravelling as "unnecessary" any regulations or systems put in place to prevent problems, and third discovering that they are ill-equipped to deal with the vagaries of the real-world.
The elements will seem familiar to us today: webs of high risk loans backed by webs of highly leveraged real-estate collateral, political turmoil in the Middle East, an indifferent government forced to intervene... you get the picture.
The setting? Rome. ca 33 AD.
The Middle East (Judea) was in turmoil because of a certain political rabble-rouser that was going around telling people to be nice to each other. (He was eventually imprisoned and killed by religous fundamentalists.)
That year, an unexpected hurricane sunk several grain ships travelling back from Alexandria to Ostia. That loss triggered calls on the loans for the merchants. Their insurers were unable to make full restitution without calling in more loan markers.
Money lending in the Roman context was a family enterprise -- the landed aristocracy would lend each other money as part of political patronage, with the family estates as collateral. They would spread these loans out as far as possible, creating a web of interlocking financial dependencies that while supposedly "spreading the risk", in reality created a house of cards that would collapse of its own complexity.
Once one of the loans was called -- it triggered a financial meltdown... and in those days, if you lost your estates, you also were likely to lose your freedom (as well as your family's).
Well, eventually, the entire Roman order was threatened and the emperor had to intervene and back the loans with the Privy Purse -- somewhat unprecedented, but then again, so was the Roman Empire.
All of which goes to show that the latest economic crisis is merely the latest in a long line of "been-there-done-that" events. It's just that we (as a society and economy) have little long-term memory when in comes down to it -- about every third generation gets in a bind by first ignoring history, second unravelling as "unnecessary" any regulations or systems put in place to prevent problems, and third discovering that they are ill-equipped to deal with the vagaries of the real-world.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
what is administrativia?
Recipes, politics, musings and more... the little and not-so-little things that make up my life...
!->
!->

Recipe Lists
Tag Cloud
AI
appetizer
asshattery
basics
beef
biden
blog
breads
breakfast
budget
cake
casserole
chicken
civil rights
clinton
cookies
coolness
cross-post
DADT
Democrats
dessert
diet
dips
economics
eggs
energy
errata
FAIL
glbt
GOP
health
history
hors d'oeuvres
Houston
Human Rights Campaign
humor
Ike
main course
mcsame
music
MWBC
no-bake
obama
oil
Out and Equal Houston
Overheard
photo
pie
politics
pork
potato
punditry
recipe
recovery
rewind
rice
salads
sandwich
shrub
side dish
soup
space
technology
tilt-shift
turkey
vegetarian
video
wingnuts
WTF?

Poltical Blogs & News
-
Monday Night2 hours ago
-
-
Noted3 months ago
-
Search10 months ago
-
-
-
-

Perry vs Schwarzenegger
News Links
Blogs & Other Favorites
- Air Quality Outlook
- Amazon
- Blogger Dashboard
- By the Bayou
- Continental Airlines
- Cooking Measurements
- Dilbert
- Earth Quake Activity (N. CA)
- Hulu
- Human Rights Campaign
- I Can Has Cheezburger
- Internet Movie Database
- Joe.My.God
- NASA
- Nutrition Data
- SiteMeter
- Snopes
- TCU
- The Bobblespeak Translation
- Towleroad
- Weird Universe
- Wikipedia
- WikipediaVision (Beta)
- YouTube
- YouTube Profile

0 comments:
Post a Comment