Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Civility.
11:16 AM | Posted by
Mike |
Edit Post
Certain elements in our society put together a plan and a coalition to deny basic civil rights to gays and lesbians -- to "lock in" their continued ability to discriminate with impunity.
"We are a democracy founded on Christian principles," they declared. "We must protect society against homosexuals for they threaten our marriages, our children and our beliefs."
They successfully engaged legislatures to block equal employment protections. They successfully engaged legislatures to block equal recognition of gay & lesbian families. They successfully engaged legislatures to block gays and lesbians from the ability to adopt or become foster parents.
But this nation is not just governed by the legislature (or an executive branch).
Our system of government provides redress from executive and legislative overreach through the courts.
So gays and lesbians (and other fair-minded straight people) availed themselves of their right to be heard in the court system. Equal protection, guaranteed by the Constitution (both the federal and of the many states), was being violated it was argued. And in many cases (not all), the courts agreed.
The cry went up from the Christianists.
"Foul! Foul! How dare the unelected judges ignore 'the will of the people' as expressed by elected representatives? This is a democracy!"
But a democracy tempered by a Constitution that seeks to provide a bulwark against minority oppression.
So, thwarted by reason and law, these elements declared that if he Constitution of the United States (and those of the many states) was the problem, then they must be changed.
And so through ballot initiative after ballot initiative, they worked tirelessly. They knew that with the right turn of phrase or outright lie they could count on ignorance and fear to "gin up" their base -- and with a little apathy from the rest of the electorate, were quite successful in passing amendments to state constitutions.
"The majority has spoken," they said. "The subject is closed. Go back in the closet. Go away and be quiet."
Except…
Those gays and lesbians (and fair-minded straight folks) hadn't finished. They were angry and upset. And they were protesting. (Sometimes quietly, sometimes loudly, sometimes with barely contained anger.)
They protested at City Halls and in town squares. They protested at Mormon Churches -- for the LDS church had bankrolled much of the effort. (The Catholic Church would have done more, but they were too busy paying off the victims of priestly child molesters.)
"Foul!", again the cry rose. "This is religious discrimination! The majority has spoken -- you're supposed to be quiet and civil and back in your place. It's your fault, you know. If you would just stop forcing your lifestyle down our throats and go back in the closet, everything would be fine. Why won't you just shut up? "
"No." said the gays and lesbians (and fair-minded straight people). "We will not be quiet. We will not step back. We will not be denied our rights. We will not be second-class citizens in our own country."
Civility does not require passivity nor does it require deference to false equivalencies or lies.
"We are a democracy founded on Christian principles," they declared. "We must protect society against homosexuals for they threaten our marriages, our children and our beliefs."
They successfully engaged legislatures to block equal employment protections. They successfully engaged legislatures to block equal recognition of gay & lesbian families. They successfully engaged legislatures to block gays and lesbians from the ability to adopt or become foster parents.
But this nation is not just governed by the legislature (or an executive branch).
Our system of government provides redress from executive and legislative overreach through the courts.
So gays and lesbians (and other fair-minded straight people) availed themselves of their right to be heard in the court system. Equal protection, guaranteed by the Constitution (both the federal and of the many states), was being violated it was argued. And in many cases (not all), the courts agreed.
The cry went up from the Christianists.
"Foul! Foul! How dare the unelected judges ignore 'the will of the people' as expressed by elected representatives? This is a democracy!"
But a democracy tempered by a Constitution that seeks to provide a bulwark against minority oppression.
So, thwarted by reason and law, these elements declared that if he Constitution of the United States (and those of the many states) was the problem, then they must be changed.
And so through ballot initiative after ballot initiative, they worked tirelessly. They knew that with the right turn of phrase or outright lie they could count on ignorance and fear to "gin up" their base -- and with a little apathy from the rest of the electorate, were quite successful in passing amendments to state constitutions.
"The majority has spoken," they said. "The subject is closed. Go back in the closet. Go away and be quiet."
Except…
Those gays and lesbians (and fair-minded straight folks) hadn't finished. They were angry and upset. And they were protesting. (Sometimes quietly, sometimes loudly, sometimes with barely contained anger.)
They protested at City Halls and in town squares. They protested at Mormon Churches -- for the LDS church had bankrolled much of the effort. (The Catholic Church would have done more, but they were too busy paying off the victims of priestly child molesters.)
"Foul!", again the cry rose. "This is religious discrimination! The majority has spoken -- you're supposed to be quiet and civil and back in your place. It's your fault, you know. If you would just stop forcing your lifestyle down our throats and go back in the closet, everything would be fine. Why won't you just shut up? "
"No." said the gays and lesbians (and fair-minded straight people). "We will not be quiet. We will not step back. We will not be denied our rights. We will not be second-class citizens in our own country."
Civility does not require passivity nor does it require deference to false equivalencies or lies.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
what is administrativia?
Recipes, politics, musings and more... the little and not-so-little things that make up my life...
!->
!->

Recipe Lists
Tag Cloud
AI
appetizer
asshattery
basics
beef
biden
blog
breads
breakfast
budget
cake
casserole
chicken
civil rights
clinton
cookies
coolness
cross-post
DADT
Democrats
dessert
diet
dips
economics
eggs
energy
errata
FAIL
glbt
GOP
health
history
hors d'oeuvres
Houston
Human Rights Campaign
humor
Ike
main course
mcsame
music
MWBC
no-bake
obama
oil
Out and Equal Houston
Overheard
photo
pie
politics
pork
potato
punditry
recipe
recovery
rewind
rice
salads
sandwich
shrub
side dish
soup
space
technology
tilt-shift
turkey
vegetarian
video
wingnuts
WTF?

Poltical Blogs & News
-
-
Hours Can Seem Like Days1 hour ago
-
Noted3 months ago
-
Search10 months ago
-
-
-
-

Perry vs Schwarzenegger
News Links
Blogs & Other Favorites
- Air Quality Outlook
- Amazon
- Blogger Dashboard
- By the Bayou
- Continental Airlines
- Cooking Measurements
- Dilbert
- Earth Quake Activity (N. CA)
- Hulu
- Human Rights Campaign
- I Can Has Cheezburger
- Internet Movie Database
- Joe.My.God
- NASA
- Nutrition Data
- SiteMeter
- Snopes
- TCU
- The Bobblespeak Translation
- Towleroad
- Weird Universe
- Wikipedia
- WikipediaVision (Beta)
- YouTube
- YouTube Profile

0 comments:
Post a Comment